Football analyst launched doping accusation to Tadej Pogacar directly: "In a few years you'll hear who actually won"

Cycling
Friday, 19 July 2024 at 10:40
tadejpogacar 2
On the Vandaag Inside, a football analyst Jack van Gelder has launched accusations of doping at the Tour de France for Tadej Pogacar specifically. The Dutch commentator was asked about the ongoing race and his response was of complete skepticism over the current performance of the yellow jersey.
Asked if he believes these performances, he reponded: "Of course not. They keep finding new things. It can't be that they keep riding faster and performing better. That's just not possible. There are limits to the human body. At a certain point, it's no longer made to do the things that we would like to be able to do in principle. It has to be faster, higher and better and at a certain point you're limited."
He continues: "Pogacar apparently doesn't have that limitation: he rides up four minutes faster than anyone in history has ever done". Pogacar rode up Plateau de Beille 3:44 minutes faster than Marco Pantani in 1998; but van Gelder's accusation is literally based on a wrong fact, since the Slovenian only climbed 1:08 minutes faster than rival Jonas Vingegaard. Van Gelder believes that eventually his victory will be removed, as has happened in the early 2000's with plenty riders. "It might be possible with body-own substances or whatever. But things happen... in a few years you'll hear who actually won."
His words brought the attention of the cycling world and Dutch journalist Thijs Zonneveld promptly responded: "Ah, Jack van Gelder is now also a medical specialist who knows exactly the limits of the human body. Maybe next time he can explain how it is possible that footballers run twice as many kilometres as in the 1970s. Or why they sprint so much faster than ten years ago. It's not about what you believe, it's not a religion. You have to prove, substantiate and investigate before you shout these kinds of things."
claps 8visitors 7
23 Comments
Mistermaumau 13 January 2025 at 11:59+ 3496

Thank you Thijs for bringing some rationality back into this pointless rant. I know of no sport that doesn’t see continuous improvement, either steadily or in erratic steps, all I see is that the average amateur now beats champions of 2-3 generations ago, this says it ALL, humans progress, all the time when they apply the collected knowledge and methods. Coming from another sport I was always surprised at how backward cycling training was in comparison, all they’ve done is catch up. There have always been individuals who lead the way in progress whilst the lower levels take more time to catch up, but catch up they always do. The 4 minute mile or 10s sprint was once seen as unattainable, I’m pretty sure Van Gelder has never looked at a list of how many have now run faster. Next is the 2h marathon. Yes, there are dopers trying to skip the line but that doesn’t mean you can just blindly accused a winner or the best. Pog is no better than Vin in certain situations, no better than MVDP in others and isn’t unbeatable, are ALL of them doping then, with the same miracle product/technique? And why is it just them, you’d imagine if it was so effective and untraceable, they’d ALL be buyers.

dabman 13 January 2025 at 04:09+ 11

Okay, so I completely agree that cycling history has shown that gains like these have ALWAYS been fueled by doping. However, personally in this case, I really don't care. Why, because this kid is so damn nice and fun and has been a positive force in cycling. Unlike Lance, who didn't care about anyone but Lance. Am I positive he is doing? No, and I'm happy to give him the benefit of doubt because he is such a fun kid.

User Avatar
James26318 30 October 2024 at 12:01+ 130

😶‍🌫️

AndyPandy 18 October 2024 at 09:21+ 38

Who the fu*k is this clown? Football analyst = shit at sports.

User Avatar
Front242 11 October 2024 at 03:31+ 20

Always a dirty dane

mobk 22 August 2024 at 21:35+ 1598

Make sure to add lots of baseless doping accusations below so that all your comments will get scrubbed by the administrators.

DH 17 March 2025 at 08:01+ 15

Forget for a second about climbing times, and look at some other numbers. Slovenia is a tiny country with a population of approximately 2.1 million people. Rather suddenly, despite its small population and its near complete lack of cycling history or development infrastructure, riders from that country have now won 8 of the last 15 Grand Tours -- and would probably have vastly more if Roglic crashed less-frequently, or Pogacar started more often. And are looking to make it 9 of 16 in a couple weeks.

That simply is not plausible.

In the long history of Grand Tours, only 6 other nations have won more than 7 -- the smallest of which by-far is 450% more populous than Slovenia, and it took the Swiss half a century to win 10, while Slovenia looks to win more than that in 5 years.

If Roglic hadn't crashed in the 2021 TdF which forced the battlefield promotion of Vingegaard, Slovenia would be sitting right now on at least 10 of the last 15 Grand Tours. That is way beyond plausible.

Both of those riders are also managing results that are nearly unprecedented at their ages, with neither being in the traditional prime for cycling. That adds to the implausibility of the situation.

The odds that two of the greatest cyclists the world has ever seen were both born and developed in the same tiny, non-cycling, country, within 9 years, are simply too long to even consider calculating.

The situation does not add up to anything legal, unfortunately. We will probably find out in a decade or two that someone in Slovenia, or working on their behalf, discovered a cocktail that works and doesn't trigger a positive test. There isn't much of a reasonable alternative -- just like there wasn't when Armstrong, also from a country with very little cycling development ( but 150 times the population ) dominated all comers.

Mistermaumau 05 February 2025 at 20:03+ 3496

Sorry but that is an amazingly naïve argument. By that standard Luxembourg should never have won any major cycling events, Jamaica would never have had a period of sprinting domination, Ukraine wouldn’t have so many world class boxers Why do we have Nurmis or Zatopeks? Because sports anomalies on the whole aren’t defined by nationality or randomly distributed, they depend on a huge range of socioculturoeconomic factors but very often it takes just one in one country to stimulate a whole swathe of people to try to become the next. Country domination comes and goes, who will take over after Pog&Rog??? The Dutch only asked this question for their own case because they don’t understand the nature of sport, you cannot find or produce MVDPs on demand, when they appear it’s an exceptional mix of coincidence, fortune, management and work. Spain, France and Italy are just waiting, and waiting for their own chance to shine again.

flywheeeeel 14 October 2024 at 12:28+ 5

Maybe van Gelder should also reflect on why Mathieu van der Poel had to urgently go to the toilet during his World Cup gold medal race. Was it from drinking too much water? Or something else? Toilet talk for van Gelder to reflect.

wisemonkey 21 July 2024 at 21:34+ 3

Needle in the buttocks, somewhere the testers never check........

TideRide32 01 March 2025 at 19:30+ 138

For Cycling I hope neither are nor would dope. It would crush the sport and leave a permanent black eye.
The super teams of Visma and UAE most likely have a lot of doctors that push the limits with their riders.
Jonas and Pogi are both great for the sport and we have very entertaining Tours when they are both competing.
The irritating part is everyone loves to call Jonas out for doping the last two years and now Pogi.
These two athletes are generation talent. Let’s enjoy the battles between them.
It would be a shame to just call someone a doper with no scientific data to back their claims.

SeenItBefore 17 March 2025 at 08:03+ 49

Lance Armstrong - Nuff said.

Ayrton 15 September 2024 at 16:49+ 150

It sure won't be Vingegaard you Dutchie

SteelFrame 30 October 2024 at 17:23+ 1148

Football analyst. LOL. Say no more.

Crashjames 02 December 2024 at 04:23+ 344

Dutch, Belgians why do you cry so much? Mvdp dominated cross this year, demolishing wout and everyone else - is he doping too? Remco also beat pantani, is he doping too?

moe14 17 March 2025 at 08:04+ 23

yes, they are

User Avatar
ScottG 11 October 2024 at 22:09+ 835

As if you know lol

Ben 05 February 2025 at 13:45+ 493

Like you know they don't.

User Avatar
ScottG 09 October 2024 at 22:51+ 835

I don't go on message boards accusing people of doping. Nice try "Ben"

SteelFrame 14 September 2024 at 15:23+ 1148

Only the guy who punctured his lung a couple months ago is riding this TDF clean!

Ben 05 February 2025 at 13:46+ 493

Well, "Scott," I'm not actually accusing anybody of doping. Just very very very very critical of all this Pogacar/UAE bullshit.

User Avatar
leedorney 09 October 2024 at 22:52+ 640

Strange how JV rides for a Dutch team and all these experts are Dutch...

maaiikeen 20 July 2024 at 20:17+ 451

I mean the person defending Tadej is also Dutch?

Just in

Popular news

Latest comments