"Shows a lack of humility towards his rivals" - Philippe Gilbert unleashes strange criticism of Pogacar
Cycling
Just a day after Tadej Pogacar claimed his first Critérium du Dauphiné title in commanding fashion, former world champion Philippe Gilbert offered an unexpected and rather pointed criticism of the Slovenian.
Writing on his personal 'X' account, Gilbert accused Pogacar of showing a “lack of humility” and suggested he may have made “the first mistake of his career.”
Read also
“A few weeks before the Tour,” Gilbert wrote, “Tadej Pogacar may have made the first mistake of his career by showing a lack of humility towards his rivals, a mistake of youth that can be corrected, because I am sure that his natural character will soon return and with it his positive image.”
What’s striking, however, is that Gilbert didn’t specify what part of Pogacar’s behaviour was problematic. Was it his aggressive riding? His post-stage interviews? His dominance? His smile?
Let’s rewind. Pogacar lost time in the time trial, and went into the final mountain stages behind Jonas Vingegaard and Remco Evenepoel. He responded by attacking hard in both mountain finishes, putting time into both rivals and sealing the overall with three stage wins. Along the way, he chased down a dangerous move from Vingegaard on Stage 1 and outsprinted Mathieu van der Poel, something few riders are capable of. Was that disrespectful?
Was it a “lack of humility” to try and win a race?
Pogacar dominated the mountain stages of the Dauphine
Pogacar is often praised precisely because he doesn’t ride defensively. He races instinctively, attacks early, and embraces the responsibility of being a leader. If he had sat on Vingegaard’s wheel or soft-pedalled to avoid appearing too dominant, would that have been more acceptable?
Gilbert’s comment raises more questions than it answers. It is not clear what behaviour he disliked. There were no gestures of arrogance, no dismissive quotes, and no public criticisms of rivals. Pogacar’s only crime seems to have been that he won, comfortably, and didn’t apologise for it.
Read also
It’s also hard not to see the irony. Gilbert was himself a rider known for aggressive racing and seizing moments when they came. In his prime, he won by dropping rivals with sheer strength and style. If anything, Pogacar is a rider very much in Gilbert’s mould: bold, instinctive, and often better than everyone else.
And so, we’re left to wonder whether the real issue here is tone or timing. Is Pogacar being criticised for winning too much? For being open about his ambitions? For racing year round when others, like Vingegaard, are still cloaked in mystery?
A quelques semaines du Tour @TamauPogi commet peut être la première erreur de sa carrière en manquant d’humilité envers ses adversaires.
— Philippe Gilbert (@PhilippeGilbert) June 16, 2025
Une erreur de jeunesse rattrapable car je suis sûr que son naturel reviendra vite et que son image positive reviendra 🙏🙌.
Fin MajorCycling Journalist
Fin Major is a UK-based writer at CyclingUpToDate and has been part of the team since 2024. He is the site’s main writer for FAQs and evergreen explainers and has written around 2,000 pieces for the platform. Alongside this work, he focuses on in-depth analysis and covers the biggest races on the calendar, including the Tour de France, the Giro d’Italia, and La Vuelta a España, providing clear context around performance trends, tactics, and key storylines.
In his reporting, Fin uses reputable data sources such as ProCyclingStats for results, statistics, and historical context. He places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles promptly when new, verified information becomes available. Outside of writing, Fin is an active cyclist, which supports his practical understanding of the sport and its demands.
claps 80visitors 18
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- many people advise him to grow slowly and rather do giro and/or vuelta instead of tdf. but i can totally understand that he is not satisfied with taking over once pogi declines, but instead beat him in his prime. so if he goes for tdf again, i‘m all for it. let‘s hope that pogi recovers soon!Ketterechts07-11-2026
- So gracious to offer something no-one would be prepared to pay for. The Giro is not the Tour and doesn’t command the same interest or attract the same “elite” (those willing to pay to be a part of something they consider has ego boosting potential). Roadside viewing will always largely remain free for everyone outside circuits. Introduction of a symbolic entrance to mountain climbs is worthy of exploration. Asking 1-2€ isn’t going to repulse real fans (most will spend 50-100€ on their outing that day all things included) but will prevent a portion of the total knobhead thrillseekers who will join in any large gathering as long as it’s free, just because they’re attracted to crowds, without which it it difficult for them to work up their anti-social behaviour.Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- How is radio going to help when someone went over a cliff or bridge or off the roadside into a forest unnoticed and is laying there unconscious?Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- Yep, next we’ll be accusing F1 drivers of avoiding Le Mans.Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- But on what is that opinion based? Are you holding him to a different standard than others? Are you saying he should do learn to like something he doesn’t Are you saying he hasn’t achieved enough Are you saying he pretends to be better than his results? It’s actually a really strange opinion to oust if you consider it objectively or rationally. Try applying it to others or yourself by asking if not EVERYONE should then be doing more? Nobody in athletics or swimming gets criticism for not expanding their repertoire when a rival or someone else does. In fact, most who move to another event get accused of running from their rival. Opinions are boring, the reasons behind them are what count.Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- for a medical chief to throw things like is just bad. There are already radios which were banned for spectacle. allow radios. Gps trackers are not a complete solutionabstractengineer07-11-2026
- Yeah man...PogiSloFans07-11-2026
- any rider less than 25 whether they are really ready for the position of leadership of GT is probably not the case. I think Pogi himself suffered when he was defeated by Jonas in the TDF twice. But that would be the team's job to ensure support so that they can bounce back. It requires a team and time to get back up and win after getting knocked down.abstractengineer07-11-2026
- I'm very glad he got the big late Quickstep Vuelta win and I hope he has a few left for Euskaltel-Euskadi.flyer07-11-2026
- My memories of Ivan Basso aren't good but I liked his sister Elisa ok.flyer07-11-2026
Loading
14 Comments