OPINION | Mathieu van der Poel’s mountain bike disaster reveals crossroads in legendary career

Mathieu van der Poel doesn’t do failure quietly. His brilliance is usually blinding, his dominance often absolute. But on Sunday in Nové Město, the Dutchman’s return to mountain biking ended not with a rainbow jersey on the horizon, but a scaphoid fracture and a harsh reminder: you can’t win everything.

The crash (two, in fact) has ruled him out of his upcoming altitude camp and cast doubt over his summer programme. While Alpecin-Deceuninck remain cautiously optimistic that his Tour de France participation is not in danger, his potential start at the Critérium du Dauphiné is already wavering. The bigger question, however, isn't about next week or even next month. It’s about what van der Poel actually wants from the final chapter of his career.

He is 30 now. In cyclocross, he is already the king, statistically and stylistically. Earlier this year he claimed a record-equalling seventh world title, and unless injury or a biblical act intervenes, he’ll claim an eighth in 2026. He’s won 169 of 228 races in the discipline. He is, quite literally, in a league of his own.

But mountain biking isn’t cyclocross. Since 2016, van der Poel has started 49 races and won just 19, an impressive record, but hardly untouchable. There are no guarantees here. The level is ferocious, and the margins thin. And unlike in cyclocross, he can’t afford to dip in and out of the calendar and still expect to dominate.

Chasing the rainbow jersey in mountain biking, the only one missing from his personal collection, isn’t a side quest. It’s a full-time commitment. It requires build-up races, targeted training blocks, and the sort of precision he would usually give to the monuments. None of that easily fits into a road calendar stacked with spring classics, Tour prep, and media obligations for the superstar. And with this latest injury interrupting his build-up, the gamble just got riskier.

Van der Poel’s desire to win that jersey is understandable. It is the title he wants more than any other, and he has said that himself. A rainbow on the dirt, to match those from the mud and the tarmac. But chasing it means sacrificing something else, and it might just be the Tour de France stage wins that have thus far eluded him.

Because for all his Monument might, van der Poel has only one Tour stage win. One. The same man who has won Milano-Sanremo twice, the Tour of Flanders three times, Paris–Roubaix three times, and dominated the worlds of gravel and cyclocross, is stuck on a solitary victory at the sport’s biggest race. A man of his talent, deserves far more than that.

At the Tour, his role is typically defined by Jasper Philipsen. Van der Poel delivers him to the final metres and peels off, and he is therefore the conductor, not the headliner. He has done it to devastating effect, but that’s not the Tour de France tale most imagined for a rider of his talent.

Wout van Aert has won nine Tour de France stages. Nine. On all terrains, in every imaginable fashion. Yes, he too has played team roles, but the freedom he's been given to win on his own terms has helped him build a stage record befitting his stature. Van der Poel? For all the flair, all the fireworks, just one.

So now, with his wrist wrapped and his calendar in flux, van der Poel faces a genuine crossroads in my opinion. The rainbow jersey in mountain biking, or Tour de France stage wins. It’s hard to see how he can chase both.

The reality is that cycling has moved past the era where raw talent alone can transcend disciplines with ease. The level is simply too high, the demands too precise. Van der Poel has gotten away with it in cyclocross because he is simply the greatest we have ever seen, and by some distance. He can dip in for a few races, arrive undercooked, and still dominate. That won’t work on the mountain bike circuit, not against riders who have spent years fine tuning every detail for 90 minute bursts of savage endurance and technical skill.

And it certainly won’t work if he still wants to leave a deeper legacy on the Tour. Van der Poel’s brilliance deserves more than one stage win at the biggest race in cycling, and the first half of this year’s Tour would offer him with the perfect opportunity to do so.

What van der Poel does next will define how we remember his 30s. He’s already an all time great, a cross-discipline genius who’s redrawn the sport’s boundaries. But even icons have to choose their battles. Right now, the greatest all-rounder of his generation is stretched across too many fronts. And Sunday’s crash, though minor, might prove symbolic, not a physical fracture, but a reminder that not even the great Mathieu can win everything.

Maybe this is the moment to let the mountain bike dream go. The rainbow jersey would be a beautiful prize, yes. But a rainbow jersey doesn’t ride down the Champs-Élysées. And Mathieu van der Poel, above all, deserves more than just one day of glory on cycling’s most hallowed roads.