“Vingegaard is not Pogacar, who would win the Giro on his own” – Italian ex-pro warns Simon Yates surprise retirement leaves Visma vulnerable
Cycling
Simon Yates stepped away at the very moment Team Visma | Lease a Bike were still building around him. The timing of his immediate retirement has already reshaped their season planning. Now an Italian former pro has gone further, warning that Yates’ absence leaves Visma exposed in the biggest races.
Moreno Moser, speaking to Bici.Pro, drew a blunt line between what Visma have lost and what that means for Jonas Vingegaard.
“He needs the team. He is not Pogacar, who would win the Giro even on his own,” Moser put forward as his argument.
That single line captures the shift created by Yates’ departure. He was not only a leader in his own right, but also a key mountain support for Vingegaard. Without him, Visma face a season in which depth, rather than star power, becomes the real question.
Losing more than a leader
Yates’ retirement removed two roles at once. He was a rider who could target general classification himself, and a rider who could act as a high level lieutenant for others. Visma’s own management admitted they had not expected the decision and that he was irreplaceable so late in the winter.
Moser sees the impact most clearly around Vingegaard. “For Vingegaard his loss is a big problem,” he said. “Yates’ departure weakens Visma considerably.”
He went further, suggesting this is not just about one rider leaving, but about a longer trend. “They were already no longer the ‘battleship’ of a few years ago, especially in the mountains,” Moser said.
That matters because Yates’ final season had underlined exactly what Visma were leaning on. He won the Giro d'Italia, then went straight into Tour de France preparation and still took a stage. He was central to their story. Removing him changes not just the line up, but the logic behind it.
Rivals with numbers and power
Moser also placed Visma’s problem in a wider context. He compared their situation to the squads around them. “Compared with Red Bull - BORA - hansgrohe and even more with UAE, Visma are at a disadvantage: they have quantity and quality,” he said.
Those teams can lose one climber and still field multiple alternatives. Visma, by contrast, now have fewer margin for error. Riders like Sepp Kuss, Matteo Jorgenson, Steven Kruijswijk and Wilco Kelderman remain, but the safety net is thinner than it was when Yates was still part of the plan.
It is not a criticism of Vingegaard’s ability, but a statement about style. He wins through structure, control and support. Take away one of the pillars of that structure and the whole shape changes.
A forced change of approach
Moser does not expect Visma to pretend nothing has happened. He believes the loss of Yates will push them toward a different racing style. “Given the weakening of the team, I already see a defensive strategy,” he said. “They will ride to save energy.”
He even predicts the reaction. “I can already hear the criticism: ‘They do not attack’, ‘They always wait’,” Moser said.
Jonas Vingegaard will lead Visma at the Giro, in search of his first ever Maglia Rosa
Searching for solutions
Moser also floated the idea that Visma may have to look in unexpected places. “And what if the man for the mountains were Davide Piganzoli?” he said.
Rather than chasing a like-for-like replacement for Yates, the team may have to reshape roles internally and accept that no single rider will fill the gap he left.
That fits with what has already emerged since the retirement. Visma have been reported as still weighing their options, with no obvious solution available so late in the winter. The market cannot easily replace a Grand Tour winner in January.
Vulnerable by timing
Yates did not leave because he could no longer compete. He left after winning the Giro and a Tour stage in the same season. Visma described that year as one of their major successes.
For the rider, it was a rare ending at the top.
For the team, it was a problem created by timing.
Without Simon Yates, Visma’s strength now depends less on one star and more on whether the structure around Vingegaard can hold. That is why, in the eyes of the Italian ex-pro, Yates’ surprise retirement has left Visma not just changed, but vulnerable.
Kieran WoodDeputy Editor-in-Chief
Kieran Wood is a sports journalist based in Wales and has been active in journalism since 2022. He regularly contributes to DartsNews.com and CyclingUpToDate.com, where he covers professional cycling and darts. In cycling, his work includes liveblogs from major races, including the Tour de France, the Giro d’Italia, and La Vuelta a España, alongside race reports and analysis. He has also conducted interviews with professional riders.
His reporting spans the full racing calendar, from one-day classics to stage races, with a focus on accurate, real-time coverage and clear contextual analysis. For statistics, results, and historical context, he regularly uses resources such as ProCyclingStats. To support reporting on rider activity and training context where relevant, he also references Strava.
In his work, Kieran places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles as new, verified information becomes available.
claps 3visitors 3
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- dude, Lemond never even was in the same race as Armstrong. He throws all these aspersions on other American riders who might usurp his throne as the greatest ever American racer. He doesn't say a single thing about (foreign) dopers who he actually raced against. Biggest douchebag move ever. I used to revere that guy, now I despise him. His actions are so weird.fatsupermodel02-11-2026
- This is just stupid, You do what you are good at not what you are weak at. He has no results to speak of when he participated. Even Froome, Conatdor had very little. With Pogi there he wont win none of the classics. he is already 30+ with a few years left at the top. It takes years to get good at classics. Is that really worth the effort???abstractengineer02-11-2026
- Sure, little fella.awp02-11-2026
- You'll be the ongoing joke of 2027 with anything you post here!frieders302-11-2026
- Awwww your inside information must be from PogiFanGirl. You two daughters of different mothers?frieders302-11-2026
- Hey PogIFanGirl...wipe that cream from your lips! You're ever loving drooling and whatever you have for Tadej has your brain fried!frieders302-11-2026
- Why should he 'let it go' ! Because you said so? Anytime LA Doper is called out is a win win !frieders302-11-2026
- Geez LeMond...let it go. You're a has been, albeit a former great one. But this is all water under the bridge and just undermines your legacy further.Mshark01-11-2026
- 'The Slovenian has collected four Tour de France titles' ... '[Kieran Wood's] ... reporting spans the full racing calendar, from one-day classics to stage races, with a focus on accurate, real-time coverage and clear contextual analysis'. i would say that is pretty inaccurate accurate coverage, kieran wood ... too bad that AI's knowledge often lags several months behind ... but proof reading is certainly part of accurate coverage, isn't it? but fortunately does Kieran Wood place 'strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles as new, verified information becomes available.' i would say the fifth tdf title is pretty new (and even verified) information, so feel free to update this article.Ketterechts01-11-2026
- You are wrong, they are already working on his new tt position. And yes, Trump does love you 😂👍🏼awp01-11-2026
Loading
2 Comments