"Pogacar is as good as he was at the Giro" - Philippa York analyses Galibier clash at Tour de France
Cycling
The fourth stage of the Tour de France saw the first big gaps open and the race is fully on. It has been a thrilling start to the Grand Boucle and as the race crossed the border into France, the climbers were once again taken to the limit, with Tadej Pogacar coming out on top with a masterful performance both up and downhill into Valloire.
"In any case, Tadej Pogačar seized his chance after an epic demonstration from his team of how to ride a short mountain stage when you have the strongest rider in the race," Philippa York said in an analysis for Cyclingnews. "Again, only Vingegaard had the capacity to react and, though he couldn’t quite reach his rival’s slipstream, it does at least show he is at a level not far from his best. A remarkable recovery when you realize a few months ago he was very badly injured and that this is his first race since April."
Read also
However this is the Tour, and the Grand Tour victory is now on the line. Whilst uphill there were not majour differences, the Slovenian created a gap in what is traditionally terrain where Vingegaard rides stronger - the high altitude. Pogacar thrived on the ascent to the Galibier and dealt an important hit (both in time and psychological) on his rival. "In the space of that last 500 metres of the Galibier, I think we saw the current state of play for everyone in that front group."
"Pogacar is as good as he was at the Giro. Evenepoel and Vingegaard are similar though their climbing characteristics differ. And then you have Carlos Rodriguez and Juan Ayuso, with Roglič dangling on the back," she adds.
On the Almeida-Ayuso incident, York didn't have any conclusions to take from the gesture, as was said too by UAE Team Emirates: "I didn’t read too much into Almeida calling Ayuso up to the front in the last kilometres of the Galibier. It was more likely that Ayuso simply was pinned in position while the Portuguese rider powered away when Yates had done his work. Nobody who found themselves in the gutter at that point looked really comfortable."
Read also

Rúben SilvaEditor-in-Chief
A founding contributor to CyclingUpToDate since its launch in January 2022, Ruben Silva has played a central role in shaping the site’s editorial direction and long-term growth. Before joining the project, he built his experience through independent blogging at Echelons Hub and by producing race previews for Ciclismo Internacional, developing a strong analytical voice rooted in daily engagement with professional cycling.
Beyond editorial work, he has been closely involved in the expansion and coordination of CyclingUpToDate’s wider network, helping establish and support sister platforms across multiple languages. This includes ongoing collaboration with CiclismoAlDia (Spanish), CiclismoAtual (Portuguese), WielrennenUpToDate (Dutch), and RadsportAktuell (German), contributing to a shared editorial vision and consistent international coverage.
He also helps oversee editorial governance across the network, setting standards for accuracy and consistency and coordinating updates or corrections when needed.
Originally from the Porto metropolitan area in Portugal, he holds a bachelor’s degree in Geography. His path into cycling journalism was shaped not through formal media training, but through independent reporting, community engagement, and sustained on-the-ground involvement in the sport.
Over the course of his career, he has conducted approximately 100 interviews across road cycling and cyclocross, ranging from one-to-one conversations and online formats to press conferences and on-site pre- and post-race coverage. His interviews include leading riders, team managers, and prominent figures within cycling media: Tadej Pogacar, Jonas Vingegaard, Mathieu van der Poel, Primoz Roglic, Wout van Aert, Joao Almeida and Tom Pidcock; managers like Patrick Lefevere and Joxean Matxin; and YouTube personality Bryan Kennedy (BKXC)...
Within 18 months of launch, he helped grow CyclingUpToDate’s English-language platform into one of the most-read cycling news websites, built entirely from the ground up. As both a professional journalist and lifelong cycling enthusiast, his focus remains on delivering accurate, timely, and well-contextualized coverage.
claps 3visitors 2
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- Go get em Wout!JoeyC18-11-2026
- I don't take my phone with me while I'm running, cycling, or swimming. And even if I had it with me, I don't need the selfie to remember or appreciate the meeting forever. The selfie is good for showing off to friends, but otherwise it's more of a TikTok vibe than something to bother with while jogging, walking, ...flyer18-11-2026
- Mas: “What I enjoy is the process leading up to the races and the racing itself.” That's always good to read. I hope his good form continues in 2027.flyer18-11-2026
- I wasn't sure if he wanted to win the TDF... some day (who would have thought it isn't about 2027). Silly me.flyer18-11-2026
- I'm in both camps in that specific races can be more interesting without Tadej. Yet I like watching him destroy the competition - probably more.flyer18-11-2026
- It was more than a backhanded compliment though. I think Lenny should have many good wins in his future.flyer18-11-2026
- It's good that Tadej, and any competitor, tries to win every race they can. Caveats could be not beating a teammate and saving oneself for upcoming races. Moser has a firm pecking order which is fine and says tactics are what's fun. I agree about tactics and I think discussing tactics is everything for commentators, but the tactics employed are sometimes overly criticized and often it's not the tactics that earn the win even with closely matched talents. Rider's performances are subject to normal variation.flyer18-11-2026
- True but if everyone's bad "luck" in this race got erased, one could argue for at least three riders.flyer18-11-2026
- A few good ideas, or parts, in a mix with crazy thoughts. Establishing how breaking contracts has to work is a good idea. His details aren't so much. Airbags? That's a flop for at least the time being. Having riders numbers be fixed through the year isn't important and has downsides but maybe the live commentators would prefer it. I don't. I don't think we need more circuits. Seems like we got what's long been decided for a reason.flyer18-11-2026
- The headline is atrocious. It implies that Thibau Nys is actually Thibau Brand, which is ridiculous. It obviously misses out his surname because it mentioned Sven, but it should say "Sven Nys explains how the Lions keep SON Thibau and..." It also makes it seem like a battle against Lidl-Trek but Sven's comments don't really fully support that.
Rafionain-Glas17-11-2026
Loading
😍 The peloton won't climb here this year, but those Lacets de Montvernier are very beautiful! 😍 Le peloton n'y passera pas cette année, mais qu'ils sont beaux ces Lacets de Montvernier ! #TDF2024
Write a comment









