Skip to content

Alongside Pogacar, can Brandon McNulty fight for a top result at the Tour de France? Remco Evenepoel might hold the key

Cycling
Collage_BrandonMcNultyTadejPogacar
Brandon McNulty has just turned World Champion with UAE Team Emirates - XRG. What would the American rider be able to do with an all-out preparation for a Grand Tour; and what could he achieve at the Tour de France if he teams up with Tadej Pogacar in 2027? On the CyclingUpToDate Podcast, Rúben Silva and Gavin Quinn have responded to these questions.
The American rider has stood out in the mountains often early in his career, but in recent years has turned into a more versatile rider, a strong time trialist who is also well capable of thriving in the hilly classics. His powers lay in his short efforts and ability to ride well on the flat, combined with defending himself on the longer climbs.
"Can he do 'a Geraint Thomas'? Can he turn himself from a time trialist into a Grand Tour specialist over the course of the next few years?" Rúben Silva asked on this week's episode.
"No. Sorry to be blunt, but I just don't see it," Quinn responded. "And I've been looking back. Of course, he's a brilliant one-day racer. The reason why we're talking about him right now is he's world champion". In Montréal, McNulty won via a long-range solo move, the type of attack and terrain he excels at.
But not distant are the memories of the 2022 Tour de France, where only Tadej Pogacar and Jonas Vingegaard could follow him in the Pyrenees; or how in the 2025 Giro d'Italia he finished in the Top10 despite racing in support of both Juan Ayuso and Isaac del Toro throughout the whole race.

One-week races, Brandon McNulty's specialty?

"He's definitely earned the right to have leadership at a Grand Tour, but that's not necessarily the question. It's whether he could win it or podium it. I think he could definitely podium a Giro or Vuelta at some point. Like, there's always that possibility. If you look at the podium of the Giro and the Vuelta over the last couple of seasons, riders can sneak in there;" Quinn argued.
But the one-week races, in which the 28-year old won plenty times in the past, should be his priority, he believes. "I would go the other way as to say Brandon McNulty can become one of the most potent stage-race contenders for UAE in 2027, and I think that's where his real strengths lie. I don't think necessarily over three weeks".
Winner of races such as the Volta a Comunitat Valenciana, Tour de Pologne and Tour de Luxembourg; McNulty's versatility and time trial ability has earned him plenty high-level triumphs. His ability on the shorter efforts recently earned him his first win in the rainbow jersey, at the Veneto Classic.
"He can pretty much win a couple of one-week races in 2027, and I think that's where the real value in McNulty lies, away from a Grand Tour. Because at a Grand Tour, he's one of the best teammates and can surely top 10, but I wouldn't put my eggs in the basket necessarily".
Brandon McNulty on stage 2 of the 2026 Tour de France
Brandon McNulty at the 2026 Tour de France, where he helped Tadej Pogacar to victory

Can Brandon McNulty race into the Top10 of the 2027 Tour de France?

"I agree that McNulty is a one-week and classic specialist, and I think that is what suits him best," Silva stated, but arguing that there is potential for more. "In the Grand Tour, I think right now, top 10 is the maximum that he can potentially achieve, if we're talking about a stacked Grand Tour, like the Tour de France [...] I think that a top five is within the cards, if he focusses in the Grand Tour, like his current self, but a Grand Tour that isn't stacked".
The 2025 Giro proved the American can handle three weeks, and hasn't yet been given an opportunity to ride for his own chances. Team manager Joxean Matxin argued he might do so soon; whilst his former team manager at Rally Cycling Jonas Carney believes the American could even win a Grand Tour.
"McNulty is definitely going to the Tour: He wants to go to the Tour de France; world champion at the Tour; good relationship with Pogacar... It just takes all the boxes, really. At the Tour, he's got 70 kilometres of time trialing".
Silva believes that if McNulty returns to the Tour de France, in the absence of Isaac del Toro and João Almeida, he could fight for his own result whilst safeguarding Tadej Pogacar. "At the Tour, as we've seen this year, Isaac Del Toro didn't have to ride for Pogacar at all. McNulty could find himself in the same role".
"McNulty could find himself in the role of being 'I'm here to support Pogacar'. If Pogacar just wipes the competition clean, as we've seen this year, he might as well do a 2025 Giro, where, well, in the time trials he just does his own thing; In the mountains, he can just hang around and do his own thing as well, and maybe ride into a Top 10".
Brandon McNulty at the 2025 Giro d'Italia, where he finished in the Top10
Brandon McNulty at the 2025 Giro d'Italia, where he finished in the Top10
Alternatively, McNulty could be given the chance to be a leader at the Giro d'Italia, with an expectedly more modest field. "I reckon that if he were selected to race and lead the Giro d'Italia, he could ride for a top five. There's a decent amount of time trialling kilometres in there. The mountain time trial, I think, would suit him perfectly as well. It's not really an obstacle".
Quinn agreed with the fact that McNulty now has the leverage to request such roles. "He's earned that right, and if that's what he wants, he can 100% top 10 a Tour. If Giro as a sole leader, or a backed leader is on the cards, it would have to be a really good race for him to top five, in my opinion".
"There's just a few too many, kind of, brutal mountain stages, mountain finishes, where the climbers are going to go nuts. But time trial kilometers are pretty long in Giro, too. There's like 57 of them. As you said, the mountain time trial is good.

Brandon McNulty to do an Evenepoel?

But Silva has proposed the possibility of McNulty doing an all-out preparation for the Tour, prioritizing long efforts and weight loss - something that Remco Evenepoel has shown, this summer, to have an immense impact on one's climbing performance.
"Take Remco Evenpoel. An Evenepoel who prepared for the Tour de France, and an Evenepoel during the season. His climbing abilities, completely different. Night and day," he added.
"If you have a McNulty actually prepare for a Tour or a Giro with the same [...] idea. Like, we're seeing the McNulty that thrives in the classics in the one-week long races. What if you have a lightweight McNulty who can sort the time trial the same, but really has that, well, successful, for this point to actually work".
"And look at Julian Alaphilippe in 2019 [at the Tour de France]. A classics specialist - He won a time trial, he was up there at the Tourmalet with the best climbers at the Tour... I think that he's one of the riders that has the most potential to sort of pull one of those surprises. And then Rainbow Jersey. Like, how iconic would that be?"
The schedules are likely to be released on the 18th of December, with the Emirati team hosting their media day right after Team Visma | Lease a Bike; and McNulty's schedule should be revealed then.
"You've turned me, to be honest," Quinn laughed. "I had 'no' literally on the first word of my notes, but it's now like a maybe, but like a positive maybe. I kind of want to see it".
"It could solve a lot of problems for UAE, because it is a good headache for them, right? Because they've no guarantees that Almeida is going to be what he was before".
claps 0visitors 0
loading

Just in

Popular news

Loading