"The solution is to make spectators understand that they must respect the riders": Tour de France director defends Alpe d’Huez safety after Rubio crash
Cycling
The chaotic scenes on Alpe d’Huez during stage 19 of the Tour de France have sparked fresh debate over spectator safety after Einer Rubio was forced to abandon following a heavy crash behind the UAE Team Emirates - XRG team car. Despite widespread criticism, Tour organisers insist they had already taken extensive measures and argue that fan behaviour, not a lack of security, remains the biggest challenge.
ASO blames modern technology and fan behaviour
Rubio crashed after Tadej Pogacar had passed him on the final climb when the UAE team car suddenly braked after a spectator fell onto the road. The Colombian smashed through the rear window of the vehicle, suffered facial injuries requiring 20 stitches, and was forced to abandon the Tour.
Tour route director Thierry Gouvenou rejected suggestions that organisers had failed to protect the riders.
“Could the accident have been avoided? Maybe every accident can be avoided once it happens, but it's clear that today's cars have sensors everywhere,” he said in words to Sporza.
Read also
According to Gouvenou, the team's modern support vehicle detected the fallen spectator, automatically braked, and even stalled. “The car detected a spectator who had fallen in front of it, braked abruptly, and the engine stopped. If we had been using cars that were twenty years older, the accident would not have happened.”
He also admitted the huge number of fans on Alpe d'Huez continues to concern organisers. “It's always astonishing to see how these crowds gather and prepare for months to come here.”
“There's a myth surrounding Alpe d'Huez that makes all the supporters want to meet at this particular place. We don't know exactly why, because the climb isn't any harder than other mountain passes. But Alpe d'Huez is legendary and everyone wants to be there. It's true there were an incredible number of people yesterday. That still worries us.”
Tadej Pogacar won stage 19 on Alpe d'Huez
Organisers insist more restrictions are not the answer
Gouvenou stressed that ASO had significantly increased safety measures compared to previous editions of the Tour. “We already took measures. We closed Alpe d'Huez the day before at 2 p.m. to prevent more vehicles from driving up.”
“Compared to previous years, we installed many more barriers. We put up ropes and posts, and deployed more police officers on the climb.”
Even so, he acknowledged that no amount of infrastructure can completely eliminate reckless behaviour. “The vast majority of spectators behave reasonably well. We see fewer people running alongside the riders, but there is still a small percentage who do all sorts of things and spoil the celebration.”
Read also
When asked whether continuous barriers along the entire climb could solve the problem, Gouvenou remained unconvinced. “You could also ban spectators,” he replied. “We can put up fences, but will the supporters stay behind them? I remember the last time in the Basque Country when we installed barriers on the final climb and the supporters simply climbed over them.”
For Gouvenou, the long-term solution lies in changing fans attitudes. “It's not that simple. Above all, it has to come from the mindset of the supporters. The solution is to make spectators understand that they must respect the riders. Restrictive measures alone will not be enough.”
He also dismissed the idea of charging fans to access iconic climbs. “That doesn't fit with the spirit of the Tour. It's a free sport for spectators. That's one of cycling's greatest strengths. That's not the road we should follow.”
Félix SernaCycling Journalist
Félix Serna is a writer at CyclingUpToDate and has been part of the team since 2025. He covers professional cycling across both the men’s and women’s calendars, with a focus on UCI rankings, race developments, and rider performance. His work includes interview-based reports, liveblogs, and tournament coverage designed to provide clear, accurate context throughout the season.
In his reporting, Félix regularly uses ProCyclingStats for results, statistics, and historical reference. He places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles promptly when new, verified information becomes available. He holds a bachelor’s degree in International Studies.
claps 2visitors 2
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- many people advise him to grow slowly and rather do giro and/or vuelta instead of tdf. but i can totally understand that he is not satisfied with taking over once pogi declines, but instead beat him in his prime. so if he goes for tdf again, i‘m all for it. let‘s hope that pogi recovers soon!Ketterechts07-11-2026
- So gracious to offer something no-one would be prepared to pay for. The Giro is not the Tour and doesn’t command the same interest or attract the same “elite” (those willing to pay to be a part of something they consider has ego boosting potential). Roadside viewing will always largely remain free for everyone outside circuits. Introduction of a symbolic entrance to mountain climbs is worthy of exploration. Asking 1-2€ isn’t going to repulse real fans (most will spend 50-100€ on their outing that day all things included) but will prevent a portion of the total knobhead thrillseekers who will join in any large gathering as long as it’s free, just because they’re attracted to crowds, without which it it difficult for them to work up their anti-social behaviour.Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- How is radio going to help when someone went over a cliff or bridge or off the roadside into a forest unnoticed and is laying there unconscious?Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- Yep, next we’ll be accusing F1 drivers of avoiding Le Mans.Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- But on what is that opinion based? Are you holding him to a different standard than others? Are you saying he should do learn to like something he doesn’t Are you saying he hasn’t achieved enough Are you saying he pretends to be better than his results? It’s actually a really strange opinion to oust if you consider it objectively or rationally. Try applying it to others or yourself by asking if not EVERYONE should then be doing more? Nobody in athletics or swimming gets criticism for not expanding their repertoire when a rival or someone else does. In fact, most who move to another event get accused of running from their rival. Opinions are boring, the reasons behind them are what count.Jumpyjohn07-11-2026
- for a medical chief to throw things like is just bad. There are already radios which were banned for spectacle. allow radios. Gps trackers are not a complete solutionabstractengineer07-11-2026
- Yeah man...PogiSloFans07-11-2026
- any rider less than 25 whether they are really ready for the position of leadership of GT is probably not the case. I think Pogi himself suffered when he was defeated by Jonas in the TDF twice. But that would be the team's job to ensure support so that they can bounce back. It requires a team and time to get back up and win after getting knocked down.abstractengineer07-11-2026
- I'm very glad he got the big late Quickstep Vuelta win and I hope he has a few left for Euskaltel-Euskadi.flyer07-11-2026
- My memories of Ivan Basso aren't good but I liked his sister Elisa ok.flyer07-11-2026
Loading
1 Comments