Dutch ex-pro calls for “competency test” before riders enter peloton: “For Jay Vine, it could have prevented a lot of crashes”
Cycling
Calls for stricter safety standards in professional cycling resurfaced this week after former Dutch rider Stef Clement argued that newcomers to the peloton should be required to pass a basic skills test before turning pro.
In quotes collected by Wielerflits from Dutch TV talk show De Laatste Etappe at the Wielergala in Utrecht, Clement laid out a blunt assessment of the current system — and why he believes it no longer meets the demands of the modern sport.
Clement opened the discussion with a self-deprecating reflection on his own bike-handling reputation, saying: “I was often told I couldn’t handle my bike properly. And looking back, they were probably right.” But he emphasised that the issue is far broader than individual riders. “There’s no sort of competency test you need to pass before you can become a pro.”
According to Clement, the pathway is too heavily weighted towards physiological numbers, with little attention paid to real-world riding skills. “You just need to prove on an ergometer that you’ve got the engine, and then you’re set loose. It’s like being allowed to drive in Formula 1 with only a tractor licence and hoping for the best. Some sort of evidence of competence, some basic bike-handling, might actually be quite useful.”
Why Clement thinks the system is flawed
Pressed by presenter Sander Kleikers, Clement was confronted with the example of Jay Vine, whose rise to the WorldTour came via the virtual-racing talent programme Zwift Academy. Clement responded directly, saying: “Well, I reckon we could have prevented a lot of crashes. For him it would have been better to do a small crash-course first.”
The point, Clement stressed, was not to single out individuals but to highlight a structural gap. Riders can enter the sport with enormous physical potential yet limited experience in high-speed bunch racing — a mismatch he believes should no longer be left to chance.
Jay Vine's crash record is used as an example to press home Clement's point
A debate that is unlikely to go away
Clement’s proposal for a formal competency test — something akin to a minimum bike-handling standard for all new professionals — adds another thread to the growing conversation around rider safety. With the sport continuing to face questions over descending speeds, bunch crashes and the increasing number of young riders entering the WorldTour at an early age, suggestions that once sounded radical are beginning to find an audience.
Whether the peloton, the teams or the UCI are willing to embrace formalised skills testing remains to be seen. But Clement’s comments reflect a wider shift: the idea that raw power is no longer enough, and that modern cycling may require a rethink of what it means to be “ready” for the professional level.
Kieran WoodDeputy Editor-in-Chief
Kieran Wood is a sports journalist based in Wales and has been active in journalism since 2022. He regularly contributes to DartsNews.com and CyclingUpToDate.com, where he covers professional cycling and darts. In cycling, his work includes liveblogs from major races, including the Tour de France, the Giro d’Italia, and La Vuelta a España, alongside race reports and analysis. He has also conducted interviews with professional riders.
His reporting spans the full racing calendar, from one-day classics to stage races, with a focus on accurate, real-time coverage and clear contextual analysis. For statistics, results, and historical context, he regularly uses resources such as ProCyclingStats. To support reporting on rider activity and training context where relevant, he also references Strava.
In his work, Kieran places strong emphasis on careful sourcing, editorial accuracy, and updating articles as new, verified information becomes available.
claps 25visitors 11
Just in
Popular news
Latest comments
- I think Jonas would have lost the TDF by 4+ minutes (at the least) and might not have even been in the top 3. Too much talent in the younger riders to say anyone not named Pogačar would have been top 3md197503-11-2026
- this is just stupid. you already have 23%, gravel is over the topabstractengineer03-11-2026
- There was once a time when Lance was supremely popular and he used his artificial "It's Not About the Bike: My Journey Back to Life" persona to lead his mob in going after Greg. There was no one Lance did not abuse in protecting his phony hero image. Lance promoted himself as a divine megastar and he let down millions of cancer victims and gullible devotees who clung far too long to the charade. Lance is the epitome of a corrupt person and because of his power, many around him, including business enterprises, succumbed to the evil. All who got in Armstrong's way were mercilessly attacked by him and his minions. This remarkably continues today with a new generation. LeMond was a number one enemy and paid a huge price. Who do you think slandered who?Yepperoni03-11-2026
- You despise him because he calls out the truth....OK clown !frieders303-11-2026
- JV is really slighting himself with not doing the 1 dayers.. 🤷
leedorney02-11-2026 - Watch the interview on youtube. I don't speak French. I do speak English and Spanish and you can hear it in his voice. Years ago LeMond had real personal problems I imagine in no small part because of Armstrong. then Armstrong goes round "full blast" re: LeMond having drinking and drug problems. The same way Andreu was expelled from mainstream cycling so was LeMond. On the positive side the clips of the ride and chatting with old teammates and was good. To seemed like a fun day and experience and good reason brush up his French.atom02-11-2026
- and another no-news article around the ‚2 tokyo jogging rounds‘ headline, this time spiced with some days old ‚news‘ that the LA and japan vacation trips come during or after the tdf route release. i am getting more and more annoyed by this time-stealing no-news crap. but who am i to complain? nobody forces me to come back for more ‚news‘ day after day …Ketterechts02-11-2026
- It would likely be a very steep section of 4.1 km, not changing the average gradient considerably, with the climb remaining 10.1 km at 11.8%. It would reach 20% on the gravel. It would start 1.6 km in, and finish with 4.2 km left to climb (before the short final descent)
Rafionain-Glas02-11-2026 - Welcome to the off-season.
santiagobenites02-11-2026 - guillaume martin in this list is quite a surprise as a gc rider.Ketterechts02-11-2026
Loading
11 Comments