Writing in his In de Waaier Substack, Zonneveld has now examined the incident in detail and reached essentially the same conclusion. “Gery deliberately tries to prevent her from responding to Vollering,” he wrote.
Zonneveld picks apart the move into the corner
FDJ had already spent several kilometres applying pressure before the decisive attack. Franziska Koch helped reduce the favourites' group before French champion Gery took over for the final lead-out towards the short, steep ramp above Nice.
Vollering passed Gery around 30 metres before the corner and immediately had clear road ahead of her. Gery then began moving back across behind her team leader.
FDJ sports director Lars Boom later told NOS: “The plan was to switch positions to the left just before the corner.” The idea was to leave space behind Vollering and force Niewiadoma-Phinney to negotiate her way around Gery.
Zonneveld believes the execution was the problem. “If Gery and Vollering had switched positions well before the corner, on the straight, it might still have been defensible,” he wrote.
Instead, his reading of the footage is that Vollering was allowed through on the outside before Gery moved across while Niewiadoma-Phinney was attempting to follow the same line.
He pointed to images from the apex which, in his assessment, show Niewiadoma-Phinney's elbow and front wheel already slightly ahead of Gery. “Gery really does move into Niewiadoma through the corner,” Zonneveld wrote.
The incident did not finish at the apex. Niewiadoma-Phinney was left with little room as they exited the bend and had to brake before reaching the pavement. Elisa Longo Borghini then came past, while Niewiadoma-Phinney eventually had to move behind Gery before finding a clear route forward.
“Deliberately boxing opponents in against the kerb? Not for me”
Zonneveld also disputes the idea that Gery and Niewiadoma-Phinney were simply fighting normally for the same position.
Gery had just completed her lead-out for Vollering and was losing speed as she came back through the group. Zonneveld argues that her movement across the road therefore served no purpose for her own position in the race beyond making Niewiadoma-Phinney's response more difficult.
“I see a lot of people who are only focusing on who takes the corner in what way, but they are overlooking that Gery is not simply fighting Niewiadoma for her own position,” he wrote.
He compared the incident with lead-out riders obstructing rival sprinters after finishing their own effort. In sprint finishes, deliberate interference can lead to relegation or disqualification. “You can say that is part of cycling, but I disagree,” Zonneveld wrote. “Plans, tactics and strategy: absolutely. But deliberately boxing opponents in against the kerb? Not for me.”
That criticism also carried a pointed reference to FDJ's own complaints during the 2025
Tour de France Femmes.
Zonneveld accuses FDJ of hypocrisy
FDJ publicly complained during the 2025 race about what the team considered a lack of respect towards Vollering in the peloton.
Zonneveld sees a clear contradiction between those complaints and what happened in Nice. “For a team like FDJ, which complained last year about the ‘lack of respect for Demi Vollering’ in the peloton, such a tactic is downright hypocritical,” he wrote.
Canyon//SRAM have since lodged a complaint with the UCI over Gery's actions. Zonneveld does not expect that process to change the overall classification. A possible fine or yellow card for Gery would punish the rider, but the 17-second Stage 8 gap and Vollering's eight-second advantage would remain.
For Niewiadoma-Phinney, the damage Zonneveld identifies happened on the road.
How much did the incident cost Niewiadoma?
Vollering accelerated as Niewiadoma-Phinney was still recovering from the corner. The Canyon//SRAM leader lost several bike lengths and substantial speed before Longo Borghini helped her regain contact. Niewiadoma-Phinney did make it back.
That first chase, however, came immediately before Vollering increased the pressure again on the steep ramp. On the second acceleration, Niewiadoma-Phinney could no longer follow.
Zonneveld believes the energy spent closing that initial gap may have been decisive. He wrote that Niewiadoma-Phinney lost several bike lengths, a huge amount of speed and “the match she needed to follow Vollering all the way to the top”.
Vollering continued over the summit, drove the descent and then pushed through the final flat kilometres into Nice. She crossed the line 17 seconds ahead of Longo Borghini and Niewiadoma-Phinney, with the bonus seconds completing a 23-second swing in the general classification.
Zonneveld ended his analysis with the biggest possible consequence. Niewiadoma-Phinney may not only have lost time in the corner, but “probably the Tour as well”.
She still has one final opportunity to overturn the deficit. Sunday's 99.2-kilometre mountain stage starts with Vollering in yellow by eight seconds, less than 48 hours after Niewiadoma-Phinney had ridden more than a minute away from her on Mont Ventoux.
The pair will now contest the Tour after two consecutive stages that have completely reversed the general classification, with Canyon//SRAM's UCI complaint and the dispute over Gery's actions still hanging over the final fight for yellow.